I have to say I find it kind of toxic in this forum that everyone who doens't completely agree with everything that Canon does is imediately classified as a troll. Because even though I would put it into different words, I kind of share the view of Cyborx, that, based on the rumored specs (!), the R5 II sounds more like a R5c II then a huge evolution (or like some youtubers call it a "wow camera") for still photographers.
Yeah, the stacked sensor, new AF algorithms, new video capabilities. New ergonomics, new EVF, new screen, eye AF..... And a pile of other things.
Well lets go through the rumored specs relevant for stills:
- 30 fps, ok that an improvement but not a game changer. Also there are no hints, that it will be able to do 14 bit in burst mode. A thing that many people had hoped for.
- new stacked sensor is nice but even the initial claims that it will be faster than the R3 have disappeard from the spec-list and are questioned in the forum (even by neuroanatomist). So the current expectation is a 6ms readout, which would make it 1,5 times slower than a Z8/9, which I find quite dissapointing.
- New AF algorithms are of course an improvement, but are you expecting additional improvement compared to (lets say) an R3 or will it rather be a catch-up then a leap forward?
- The Eye-AF was indeed a feature I had hoped for when I first heard of it, but after hearing almost nobody uses in in the field, I can't even understand why Canon decided to opt for it instead of the smart-controller.
Genuinely curious—what would an improved R5 realistically look like to you?
I can't answer for Cyborx but my expectations for an improved R5 (for still shooters) would be quite simple and IMHO are actually not that unrealistic.
- Improvement of the firmware shortcomings in the R5 like the missing acoustic feedback in ES or the inability to select different burst speeds in ES
- 30 fps burst with (!) a 14-bit readout
- fast stacked sensor that has a readout on par with the Z8, so 4ms or less readout speed for stills.
- Allow flash in full ES-mode, with sync-speed of 1/200 or better 1/250.
- Better buffer handling, meaning that it only reduces the burst-rate when the buffer is full instead of locking up the camera
- Usable pre capture feature with a configurable amount of images and that creates individual raw-files and not that stupid roll-file
- Inclusion of the smart-controller (insead of the complicated and not-so-much-liked Eye-Control-AF)
BTW i put the the things in italic that could easily be backported to the existing R5 with a firmware update.